← Back to list
Pabrai Wagons ETFArticle30 Jun 2024Source: wagonsfund.b-cdn.net

Pabrai Wagons|年度股东信|2024-06-30

In plain words

This is a letter from fund manager Pabrai to his investors. He thinks the S&P 500 is expensive (P/E of 27.5, higher than the 2000 dot-com bubble), while his fund's stocks trade at just 7.5 times earnings, so he expects to beat the index going forward. The fund is heavily invested in four areas: Turkish airports and drinks (TAV Airport Holdings, Anadolu Efes, Coca-Cola Icecek), U.S. coal (Arch Resources), U.S. car dealers, and homebuilders. These are long-term holdings, and the fund is concentrated.

AI SummaryAI-generated · may contain errors · verify against the original

At a Glance

One-sentence summary: Pabrai believes the S&P 500 valuation is approaching bubble levels (P/E 27.5x), while the fund's portfolio trades at just 7.5x, making outperformance "reasonable" going forward. Stance: [Cautious].

  • From inception to July 31, 2024, the fund has gained 32.65% cumulatively, outperforming the S&P 500's 30.34%, without heavy exposure to tech stocks.
  • The S&P 500's current P/E of 27.5x exceeds the 25.6x level during the 2000 bubble, while the long-term average is just 16x.
  • 94% of the fund's holdings are concentrated in four sectors: core Turkish assets, U.S. coal, U.S. auto dealers, and U.S. homebuilders.
  • The top five holdings are TAV Airport Holdings (12.2%), Anadolu Efes (10.5%), Coca-Cola Icecek (10.2%), Arch Resources (7.0%), and Alpha Metallurgical Resources (5.4%).
  • The author reiterates the investment philosophy: exceptional returns come from a few great companies held for the long term, and the fund will "build a wagon train around its highest-conviction positions."
~9 min full read · 5 sections
Deep Analysis

First Year Outperforms S&P 500 Without Heavy Tech Allocation

Performance Comparison: From inception on September 29, 2023, to June 30, 2024, WAGNX rose 24.64% and WGNIX rose 24.86%, slightly trailing the S&P 500's 28.77%. However, as of July 31, 2024, WAGNX had accumulated a gain of 32.65% and WGNIX 32.97%, outperforming the S&P 500's 30.34%. For the year-to-date period through July 31, 2024, WAGNX gained 23.03% and WGNIX 23.19%, significantly ahead of the S&P 500's 16.70%. The author emphasizes that the fund achieved this performance without heavy exposure to the tech stocks driving the S&P 500's gains, such as NVIDIA.

S&P 500 Valuation Nears Bubble Levels, Fund Portfolio P/E at Just 7.5x

Market/Macro View: The author holds a [cautious] stance on the S&P 500. He notes that in September 2000, the S&P 500's price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio was 25.6x, and the subsequent 11-year return was nearly zero. Currently, the S&P 500's P/E stands at 27.5x, almost on par with the 2000 level and well above the long-term average of 16x. The author believes that while the S&P 500 could continue to rise for a few more quarters, buying at a P/E above 25x carries high risk. In contrast, the fund's portfolio has a P/E of just 7.5x. The author states: "We believe the odds of our outperforming the S&P 500 from here are plausible."

Portfolio Concentrated in Four Key Areas, with Turkey and U.S. Coal at the Core

Position Moves (all held for observation, no explicit new positions, additions, or reductions disclosed): As of June 30, 2024, the fund held 27 global stocks, with 94% of the portfolio concentrated in four sectors:

  • Turkish Core Assets: TAV Airport Holdings (12.2%), Anadolu Efes (10.5%), Coca-Cola Icecek (10.2%), AG Anadolu Grubu Holding (4.0%). The author refers to these as the "Turkish main force," noting that Coca-Cola Icecek operates in 11 countries, Anadolu Efes is Turkey's largest beer brand, and TAV operates airports in 8 countries.
  • U.S. Coal: Arch Resources (7.0%), Alpha Metallurgical Resources (5.4%), Consol Energy (4.1%), Warrior Met Coal (4.0%), covering both thermal and metallurgical coal.
  • U.S. Auto Dealers: Asbury Automotive (4.0%), Penske Automotive Group (3.9%), Lithia Motors (3.7%), AutoNation (3.6%), Group 1 Automotive (3.3%).
  • U.S. Homebuilders: PulteGroup (3.6%), Toll Brothers (3.3%), Tri Pointe Homes (3.3%).

Other holdings include: Occidental Petroleum (3.9%), Danaos (3.8%), Daqo New Energy (3.3%), Amazon.com (1.5%), Microsoft (1.0%), Mongolian Mining (0.5%), Topicus.com (0.5%), Restaurant Brands International (0.3%), Spirit Airlines (corporate bond) (0.2%), Tiny (0.1%), Constellation Software (0.0%). Cash accounts for 0.9%.

Investment Philosophy: Long-Term Holding of a Few Great Companies

Outlook and Risk Disclosure: The author reiterates the fund's investment philosophy—that exceptional investment returns typically come from a small number of great investments held for the long term, with the key being to "find and hold." Drawing an analogy to the defensive tactics of American pioneers, the fund will "circle the wagons around the highest-conviction positions." The author hopes to be "smart enough to hold the companies in the current portfolio for the long term." Risk Disclosure: The fund is non-diversified, and concentrated holdings may amplify individual stock volatility; investments in small- and mid-cap companies carry liquidity risk; holding a large cash position may cause the fund to miss market upside opportunities. On fees, the retail class net expense ratio is 1.25%, and the institutional class is 1.00% (contractually reduced through October 31, 2025).


Position Moves

Ticker Direction Author's One-Sentence View Key Data
TAV Airport Holdings Hold & Watch Core Turkish asset, operates airports in 8 countries, highest allocation Position 12.2%
Anadolu Efes Hold & Watch Turkey's largest beer brand, core holding Position 10.5%
Coca-Cola Icecek Hold & Watch Turkey's beverage leader, operates in 11 countries Position 10.2%
Arch Resources Hold & Watch US coal, covers both thermal and metallurgical coal Position 7.0%
Alpha Metallurgical Resources Hold & Watch US metallurgical coal producer Position 5.4%
Consol Energy Hold & Watch US coal company Position 4.1%
Warrior Met Coal Hold & Watch US metallurgical coal producer Position 4.0%
AG Anadolu Grubu Holding Hold & Watch Turkish holding company, core holding Position 4.0%
Asbury Automotive Hold & Watch US auto dealer Position 4.0%
Occidental Petroleum Hold & Watch US oil and gas company Position 3.9%
Penske Automotive Group Hold & Watch US auto dealer Position 3.9%
Danaos Hold & Watch Container shipping company Position 3.8%
Lithia Motors Hold & Watch US auto dealer Position 3.7%
AutoNation Hold & Watch US auto dealer Position 3.6%
PulteGroup Hold & Watch US homebuilder Position 3.6%
Group 1 Automotive Hold & Watch US auto dealer Position 3.3%
Toll Brothers Hold & Watch US homebuilder Position 3.3%
Tri Pointe Homes Hold & Watch US homebuilder Position 3.3%
Daqo New Energy Hold & Watch Chinese polysilicon producer Position 3.3%
Amazon.com Hold & Watch Tech giant, small position Position 1.5%
Microsoft Hold & Watch Tech giant, very small position Position 1.0%
Mongolian Mining Hold & Watch Mongolian coal company Position 0.5%
Topicus.com Hold & Watch Canadian software company Position 0.5%
Restaurant Brands International Hold & Watch Fast-food chain (Burger King, etc.) Position 0.3%
Spirit Airlines (Corporate Bond) Hold & Watch Bond of a US airline Position 0.2%
Tiny Hold & Watch Canadian holding company Position 0.1%
Constellation Software Hold & Watch Canadian software giant Position 0.0%