Kopernik's latest letter describes Wall Street's mood as a party, arguing that some form of debt jubilee (widespread debt forgiveness) may be unavoidable. The firm is cautious and sees a split: long-term bonds and U.S. stock indexes look unattractive at record valuations, with speculation widespread, while beaten-down value stocks and resources are forming bargains. In the recent pullback it added to Royal Gold (28% below recent historical levels) and platinum miners Impala and Sibanye (about 50% below recent highs).
Kopernik's report opens with the song "Bayou Jubilee" as a prelude, discussing the current market and the "debt jubilee" theme. The report notes that despite high inflation, rising interest rates, massive debt, staggering budget deficits, and frequent geopolitical conflicts, Wall Street is still par
Stance: [Cautious]. This chapter is an introduction; it does not address performance or holdings. Kopernik uses the "party" imagery of the song "Bayou Jubilee" to compare Wall Street's "carnival" in the face of inflation, interest rates, debt, deficits, geopolitical conflict, and declining institutional trust to a ball, and introduces this issue's theme: a debt jubilee (large-scale debt relief/cancellation) may be an unavoidable outcome. The author explicitly states that the stock market is not the topic of discussion and takes no bullish or bearish stance on it.
Kopernik's market judgments and key figures in the introduction are as follows:
| Indicator | Data/Judgment Provided by the Author |
|---|---|
| Buffett indicator (total market cap/GDP) | All-time high, nearly four times its level of twenty years ago |
| Market valuation | Market cap relative to book value, revenue, replacement value, and CAPE all at record highs |
| Dollar purchasing power | Down more than half over the past 30 years |
| Dollar vs. gold | Depreciated more than 99.5% over the past century |
| Fiscal deficit | The government seems able to bear roughly $2 trillion in annual deficits |
| 30-year Treasury yield | Rose sharply after 2021; the accompanying chart's vertical axis spans roughly 1.5%–5.5% |
| History of debt jubilees | At least 4,000 years, dating back to Sumer and Babylon; ancient Israel every 50 years; Solon (6th century BCE) used partial debt relief |
The main arguments are broken down as follows:
1. The market is in a state of "carnival detached from fundamentals." The author describes Wall Street's response as "Party. Fais do-do! Jubilation." and quotes Chuck Prince, former chairman and CEO of Citigroup: "When the music stops, in terms of liquidity, things will be complicated. But as long as the music is playing, you've got to get up and dance. We are still dancing." This quote is used to capture the market's mindset of continuing to revel despite knowing it is unsustainable.
2. The U.S. Treasury bull market most likely ended in 2021. 2021 was the 40th anniversary (Ruby Anniversary) of the U.S. Treasury bond; the author says the bond market has since been "a sea of red," with the 30-year Treasury yield rising markedly. This sets up the introduction of the "debt jubilee" concept: large-scale debt relief or cancellation.
3. Current debt levels cannot be repaid with equivalent economic value. The author believes the United States and most other governments have no will to restore fiscal order, and history also shows that current debt levels are unsustainable; "debt that cannot be repaid will ultimately not be repaid." Paying 2026 debt with 2026 dollars would in practice become paying with 2056 dollars of greatly diminished purchasing power, and the author finds it "inconceivable" that the purchasing power of the two would converge.
4. Debt holders face institutional and legal erosion. The author lists: mortgages have been relieved, student loans and rents have been deferred, LMEs (liability management exercises) have become common; the private credit space has recently seen increasing use of gate clauses (restricting or suspending redemptions), implying "wealth redistribution is underway." The author's admonition to debt holders is "Caveat Emptor" (buyer beware).
5. Debt jubilees have deep historical precedent and also serve as a "system reset." The author quotes Lyn Alden: ancient rulers often canceled debt for social stability rather than benevolence; it was equivalent to restarting a "social system" that had malfunctioned due to debt accumulation, otherwise the imbalance could settle itself through violent revolution. The author thus implies that the current debt carnival cannot last forever, and some form of debt reset may become the way out.
Finally, the author emphasizes that although the outlook is "not rosy, but gem-red, scarlet warning signals," he will not downplay the severity of the challenges, while also arguing that "there is still a little joy worth preserving"—a setup for subsequent chapters. This chapter does not address specific holdings, individual stock commentary, or portfolio position changes.
The author continues his stance of being bearish on bonds and U.S. stock indices, and bullish on beaten-down value stocks. The overall judgment is [Cautious / Divergent]: the index level is unattractive, but opportunities abound at the individual stock level.
In the latest pullback, the author repurchased gold mining stocks sold earlier this year and added to platinum mining stocks; resource positions shrank significantly as prices fell.
| Name | Direction | Key Figures |
|---|---|---|
| Royal Gold | Add | 28% discount from its recent historical level |
| International Tower Hill | Not specified (author says "looks good") | Nearly 40% below February level |
| Novagold | Not specified (position was trimmed four months ago) | Down 45% from the price at the time of trimming |
| Valterra | Adding back | 40% discount from recent high |
| Impala | Adding back | 50% discount from recent high |
| Sibanye | Adding back | 50% discount from recent high |
The author lists a batch of "valuable, essential, hard-to-replicate" assets and franchises that he believes have fallen to attractive valuation ranges.
This section uses "perpetual contracts (perps)" as its main thread, outlining their encroachment on traditional exchanges, their speculative role in the SpaceX listing, and the aggressive innovation of crypto perps. The report's stance is [neutral to skeptical]—it acknowledges perps' price discovery function, but throughout emphasizes volatility and speculative chaos.
1. Established exchanges face perps competition, and regulators may step in with restrictions. The report notes perps pose a competitive threat to CME, which has a 128-year history, with CME shares down 14% over the past month. CME announced it would offer 24/7 trading contracts for crude oil futures starting June 30, but Bloomberg reported the next day that the CFTC might block the plan over concerns that over-the-counter trading could amplify market volatility amid geopolitical tensions. The author does not take a position on regulatory intervention itself, brushing past it with "regulatory snafus and all."
2. Perps have become the hottest speculative instrument of the day, with the SpaceX listing as their perfect stage. The report refers to participants as "punters" and provides two sets of data:
| Platform | Perps trading volume on SpaceX listing day |
|---|---|
| Hyperliquid | Over $1.2 billion |
| Binance | $5.6 billion |
| Total | Roughly one-tenth of Nasdaq's dollar trading volume |
The report believes that with SpaceX having issued only about 4% of its float, permps "arguably contribute to price discovery, though not without growing pains." The violent swings in SpaceX's share price serve as a footnote:
| Time | SPCX market cap |
|---|---|
| Monday regular trading close | $2.5 trillion |
| Hours later (Hyperliquid) | Jumped to $3 trillion |
| Tuesday cash trading close | $2.64 trillion |
Bloomberg reported that a sharp rise in financing rates on short positions triggered a "classic short squeeze"; according to Coinglass data, more than $50 million of short positions were liquidated Monday evening.
3. Crypto perps are accelerating expansion with extreme leverage, far removed from traditional investment frameworks. The report describes Bittam Exchange announcing the launch of crypto perps, attracting customers with a $300 reward for new user registration, and emphasizing no KYC (know-your-customer rules), instant trading (account opening within seconds), and leverage up to 200x. The author dryly comments that this is "slightly outside the Graham-and-Dodd investing curriculum," suggesting such products have almost nothing to do with the value investing tradition. The report does not disclose whether Kopernik participates in any of the above markets or holds related positions. Investors should note this is a monthly commentary from the perspective of a position holder, not trading advice.